Maybelline Natural Smokes Quad
Honestly, I bought this quad just for the taupe lid color. I was surprised by how much I liked the rest of the shades. They swatched better than they showed up on my eyes, but are definitely pigmented enough for daytime use. I would repurchase.
Designer Chocolates Quad
I was so disappointed by this beautiful cranberry shade, as well as the other three in this quad. The pigmentation is just bad. Keep in mind I don't use primer when swatching, but these need a lot of work to be usable on the eyes.