Here is a comparison of some Nude lipliners I have in my stash. Some are very new to me and some are old ready to trash, but for color comparison, here they are.
As you can see, for the most part they are all very similar. My most used is my MUFE 1C. Smashbox is my deepest one and is very similar to the It Cosmetics Blushing Nude. NYX Nude Pink is the most pink.
I was upset to open the Mac one and see white mold on the tip. In the trash it is going. The Jordana is dried up, and I don't even know if they still carry it, but if they do, it is very close to most of the others and a great cheap alternative.
The smoothest application will be the creamier pencils like the It, Mally, and MUFE. The rest are all drier pencils.
I still want to try Trish McEvoy and Bobbi Brown lip liners. I wouldn't say any of these are my HG yet. I am testing out the It Cosmetics one today, and so far I am really liking it.
What is your favorite nude liner?